Click here for important information about Computing.net.
How can I save a file in two different folders that, whenever I open it from either, and save it, the changes will be saved in both files.
Thanks. Saul
Not sure this will work on a Mac, but it does on my Excel 2000, XP. (Caveat Emptor) You can Link two workbooks the same way you link worksheets.
Open WorkbookA
Open WorkbookBIn cell A1 in WorkbookB you will need to put a formula like:
=[BookA.xls]Sheet1!$A$1
Which contains the Book Name, Sheet Name and Cell reference.
Now as long as both books are open,
the B workbook will automatically update when you enter data into A.Now if B is closed, then upon opening B the first time, you will get a message asking if you want to update.
Did a bit more testing and it seems if the two workbooks are NOT in the same directory, it won't work. Sorry.
A bit more testing again, and it seems you need to supply the complete path name in Workbook B, something like: ='C:\Documents and Settings\Owner\My Documents\[BookA.xls]Sheet1'!$A$1
Even then it's not guaranteed to work.
Someplace along the line, Workbook B is modified, so the complete path name is removed.
Perhaps someone else will have an answer.
Ok, this is getting a bit weird. If Workbook A and Workbook B are in separate directories,
then you need to supply the complete path name in Workbook B IE:='C:\Documents and Settings\Owner\My Documents\[BookA.xls]Sheet1'!$A$1
After entering data into Workbook A, saving and closing Workbook A
if you then navigate to Workbook B, open it, it will ask you if you wish to update.
Answering yes updates Workbook B to reflect the changes in Workbook A.Now here is the strange part,
If you have Workbook A closed and open Workbook B, the formula will display as shown above with the complete path, but if you now open Workbook A, while also having Workbook B open, then the formula reverts to the
=[BookA.xls]Sheet1!$A$1
If you then close Workbook A the formula reverts back to the complete path.
So it will work, but boy is it flakey.
Hi Mike.
Thanks for trying that.
I know what you mean. In 2008 for Mac it works the same way, if I write in cell A1 in workbook 1 the formula "=[Workbook2]Sheet1!$A$1" then every change I will write in A1 workbook 2 will be changed automatically in work 1, and then if I copy format to the whole sheet(s) I can link the whole sheet(s).
But it is pretty complicated, besides, you then can write only on workbook 2, because the moment you write in workbook 1 it erases the formula and the cells are not linked anymore.I am looking for a way to open either of the workbooks, 1 or 2, make changes and the changes will be made also in the second workbook.
I think MS dropped the possibility of using VBA in 2008 for Mac (and even if they didn't I don't know how to do it)...
Here are 2 macros that work for Windows based Excel installations. Sorry, I can't tell you how to handle this on a Mac. The first (DualSave) opens the Save As dialog box so you can choose a location, saves the file there and then opens the Save As dialog box again so you can choose a different location.
The second (AutoDualSave) automatically saves the file to My Documents and the Desktop.
As written, both of these macros need to be run manually. However, they could be placed inside the BeforeSave event and run automatically when you choose Save.
Sub DualSave() ' ' DualSave Macro ' Macro Written 6/25/2005 by DerbyDad03 ' 'Get Filename, Default = FileName fileSaveName = Application.GetSaveAsFilename() 'Save File to Chosen Location If fileSaveName <> False Then ActiveWorkbook.SaveAs Filename:=fileSaveName End If 'Do it again fileSaveName = Application.GetSaveAsFilename() If fileSaveName <> False Then ActiveWorkbook.SaveAs Filename:=fileSaveName End If End SubSub AutoDualSave() ' ' AutoDualSave Macro ' Macro Written 6/25/2005 by DerbyDad03 ' 'Disable Alerts 'Don't tell the user that the file already exists Application.DisplayAlerts = False 'Save the file to MyDocuments ActiveWorkbook.SaveAs Filename:= _ "C:\Documents and Settings\user_name\My Documents\Book1.xls" 'Save the file to the desktop ChDir "C:\Documents and Settings\user_name\Desktop" ActiveWorkbook.SaveAs Filename:= _ "C:\Documents and Settings\user_name\Desktop\Book1.xls" 'Enable Alerts Application.DisplayAlerts = True End Sub
Thanks Derby, but Excel 2008 does not support macros or VBA.
You'll just have to break down and learn Applescript and convert the VBA to something you can use. :-)
Well... apparently you are right (and apparently it could be a good joke if it wasn't true)... :-)
Anyway, at least something good came out of my question. I visited your site (don't know if it's YOURS, the skeptic one) and I liked it....
:-)
Hey! I'm deeply hurt. IMO, more good than just a visit to Mike's site came out of your question.
My code suggestions should give you the basics on how to accomplish your goal, as long as you can find an way of using the logic in a scripting language that is compatible with Excel 2008.
To ignore the "goodness" provided by my post cuts me to the core. ;-)
Not my site, just one that I find of interest. And DerbyDad03 is correct
if you get around to working with Applescript, the logic should work just as well,
and don't let his outrage fool you, he loves doing this stuff.
OK guys, got the picture. Rolling my sleeves and starting learning AppleScript! (Derby, I will use your macro as the platform to build my script)... :-)
(Will that do for you to stop being cut to the core?)... :-)
Thanks both of you for your help.
Enjoy this coming week.
Smiles. Saul
I getting better, slowly.
| Yes (14) |  | |
| No (14) | | |
| I don't know (15) | |
Ad Choices