Computing.Net > Forums > Windows XP > Which is better, please help

Computing.Net: Over 1,000,000 posts about all things technology related! Over 90% answered within 24 hours! Click here to sign up now, it's free!

Which is better, please help

Reply to Message Icon

Original Message
Name: enik
Date: January 29, 2007 at 19:02:36 Pacific
Subject: Which is better, please help
OS: Windows XP
CPU/Ram: AMD Athlon 1900
Comment:

Which is a better processor?
Intel Pentium D 820 Dual core 2.8 GHz
or
AMD Athlon X2 Dual Core 4200+ 2.2 GHz

Please help as I have to decide between only these two for my new computer.

Thanks


Report Offensive Message For Removal


Response Number 1
Name: terii
Date: January 29, 2007 at 19:15:24 Pacific
Reply: (edit)

This quote is taken from Windows Secrets.

"But note: While benchmarks can point you in the right direction, they're not gospel. In fact, small performance differences really don't matter much at all because of human physiology. Most people — the mythical "average users" — are relatively insensitive to speed differences of less than about 15–20%.

I know that sounds hard to believe, but it's true. It's something I've seen time and again in the various PC testing labs with which I've been involved (Byte Magazine, Windows Magazine, NTSL, etc.).

People who live at their PCs all day, every day, are somewhat more sensitive than casual users and can often detect speed differences in the 10–15% range. PC testing professionals are the most speed-sensitive of all, and they often can detect differences in the 5–10% range. Lower than that, and almost everyone needs a stopwatch or other instrumentation to reliably detect PC speed differences. In other words, small speed differences fall below the threshold of human perception and, thus, don't matter a lot.

Plus, in most normal uses, PCs spend the majority of their time waiting for something to happen — a keystroke or mouse movement, a bit of data to arrive, or whatever. In between those actions, the PC is sitting there, mostly just twiddling its figurative thumbs. Whether it twiddles slightly faster or slower really doesn't matter much, and has no perceptible effect on the user experience.

All of which adds up to this: It's not worth agonizing over a few percentage points, one way or the other, in performance tests. Unless you're doing something very unusual with your PC, just about any of today's midrange and higher PCs will probably serve you well. Thus, you can focus on other important factors, such as the other components in the system, price, service, the software included with the system, and so on. Small performance differences among and between CPU types simply aren't something that will change your life for better or worse!"

Hope this helps.


Report Offensive Follow Up For Removal

Response Number 2
Name: jam
Date: January 29, 2007 at 22:20:51 Pacific
Reply: (edit)

OK, now that that's out of the way....

It would depend on the configuration (motherboard, RAM, etc) & what you use the system for. The A64 X2 4400+ would *probably* be the better choice

http://www23.tomshardware.com/cpu.h...


Report Offensive Follow Up For Removal







Post Locked

This post is quite old and has been locked from receiving new replies. Please create a new posting instead.


Go to Windows XP Forum Home








Do you own an iPhone?

Yes
No, but soon
No


View Results

Poll Finishes In 7 Days.
Discuss in The Lounge
Poll History




Data Recovery Software