Tom's Guide | Tom's Hardware | Tom's Games
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
Name: srloren
I think I read that you are not supposed to defrag your partition that you keep backups on. Does defragging that partition make restore difficult? TIA
srloren

I use Microsoft On-line Safety Scanner
http://safety.live.com/site/en-gb/d...
This give options to defrag if required all partitions...

Perhaps I should clarify. I use the Backup and Restore software that comes with Windows XP Pro. I create it on a separate partition. While defragging I included this partition then thought about whether I was supposed to defrag or not. A little late. I have the option of doing another backup after running scandisc and defrag. I am really asking if anyone else has read about not defragging a a backup partition. Thanks again guys, just trying to keep my system in order.
srloren

IMO Defrag is best used on partitions where files & folders are constantly opened, added, moved about, edited, copied or deleted, and not on partitions that merely hold backup or images. The latter rarely get fragmented.
i_XpUser

XpUser isabsoultely correct. But to answer your question, it's ok to defrag a backup partition. It will not do any harm,

srloren,
frankly, personally I don't see any sufficient reason for defragmentation nowadays. Now the drive sector size is too small compared to the size of files. Besides, now repositioning of HDD head is fast enough, which makes defragmentation pluses very doubtful. So, I just don't defrag nigther usual partition nor the backup partition

Despite skeptics' claims, file fragmentation is still a serious issue even with NTFS. Faster/larger drives do not solve the problem since file sizes have also grown in parallel over the years. It's not only a question of poor performance from files scattered around the the platter in little fragments, but also mechanically overworking the drive unnecessarily - generating heat and reducing drive life. A heavily fragmented drive is in a diseased state of health..cannot perform to it's full potential.

![]() |
two network icons
|
spoofing system spec ...
|

This post is quite old and has been locked from receiving new replies. Please create a new posting instead.
| Ads by Google |