Tom's Guide | Tom's Hardware | Tom's Games
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
Hello, I searched high and low and can not find an answer, so here I am :)
I reinstalled Windows overtop the itself to straighten out some problems and it reported that I had NO bad sectors during the reinstallment. I ran scandisk and found that I had 581,632 Bytes in Bad Sectors to my surprise. I then used HDD Regenerator 1.41 to see if it could be fixed. HDD Regenerator repaired 6 bad sectors. I ran ScanDisk again and got the report as to having 581,626 bad sectors. I ran HDD Reg 1.41 again and it said everything was fine. Ran ScanDisk one more time and it still had the same report of 581,626 bad sectors. I don't know what to believe or what else I should try. Can anyone please help me with this problem? Thanks

Try using the software designed for your hard drive...go to the drive manufacturer's website & download their diagnostics program.
Or try here:
http://www.benchmarkhq.ru/english.html?/be_hdd2.html
Asus A7N8X-X
1800+ @8x210mhz
512mb PC3200
Ti4200/8X 128mb
WDC 60GB

Hi
The integrity of the starage surface can determined by a range of programs. Some will be lax and some are more through. How they can determine trouble can vay as well. (sorry - I don't have a proper answer for you)
Suggest you try the hard drive diagnostic generally available at the manufacture's website.

You can force ScanDisk for Windows to retest bad clusters by modifying the value
for the following registry key:
HKEY_CURRENT_USER\Software\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion\Applets\Check Drive\Settings
This registry key will exist only if ScanDisk for Windows has already ran once.
To have ScanDisk test clusters that have been marked as bad, modify the Settings
value so that the last two digits are "04." For example, if the current value
for Settings is
B1 03 40 00
change it to read:
B1 03 40 04
Once you modify the value for Settings, ScanDisk for Windows will retest any
clusters marked as bad. This only lasts one time.******************************************************************************

I think you have to use the hard drive manufacturers utility to fill the hard drive with zeros (to create a factory clean hard drive) then format after partitioning. If HDD regenerator did clear some bad sectors then your report will now show fewer or no bad sectors.
I believe that once windows has recorded a sector as bad it will not put it back to clean. I could be wrong though.
___________________________________________
☺ When everything else fails, read the instructions.

Scandisk 'fixes' a bad sector by marking it bad so the OS won't use it. I'm not familiar with HDD regenerator but perhaps it does the same thing. Or maybe it retested the sectors marked bad and found that they were actually bad.
Occasionally spots get marked bad that are actually good but there's no way to repair a spot that really is bad.

Good Afternoon,
I tried Jams links and found it of no use but thankyou Jam ;)the manufacturer of my computer has no diagnostic tools for my computer but does have for newer models.I saw a webpage somewhere just today about what jubalsams mentioned. I would like to know more about it first. My goal is to find out if my HD is really fixed or made to look fixed. I'd rather know for certain before deciding to do a full format. I hate full formats because it means reinstalling the screen calibration, modem drives to every other little detail etc. I've heard some say that HDD Regenerator is great but how do I know that those people are not working for a scam artist. How will I know that HDD Regenerator is a scam or not. wink!!! :) This is something I have to question because ScanDisk tells me a different story.

Hi
You could use a generic tester available from ontrack. Its a 30 day trial tool, but I've found it useful.
Scandisk can get it wrong in a few situations, but this generally involves scandisk being corrupted or a virus infection. That reminds me there was some method to remove the mapped bad sectors without going into the registry, but I'm coming up blank at the moment. Perhaps it was a batch file. During virus removal, something had to remap the drive , and free all the clusters which weren't really bad. I'm geting #$%# annoyed I can't remember the specifics - anyhow probably a sign I should sleep more.
On another note -- What is your hard drive --the brand and model.
I'd suggest you get another drive and ghost or image or just plain copy the drive across to the new one.
A lot of utilities cash in on this apparent cluster recovery.
There are a couple of things that can happen to the media surface.
Physical damage, which is common in most drives as they slowly wear out. Some of the diagnostics used to have utilities where you could shift in spare tracks. With high capacity drives these days, they may have realised its not worthwhile to do. Generally there is a underlying cause when the physical tracks are damaged. Remapping some spare cluster in, may be possible. However, you could not entirely trust the drive, not unless the physical damage was a result of a bump etc and was not likely to happen again.
The next -- From factory the surface media is not magnetically perfect. The drive leaves with a "defect list" from a factory scan. This is stored somewhere outside of the normal data area, eg. you can completely fill the drive from the first CHS (0,0.0) to the end of the drive and will not write over it. Its probably where the Drive ID is stored as well.
Over time, from this imperfection in the media surface, there can be what is called "growth".
I gathered from some reading some time back, this means the surface has trouble switching magnetic polarity meaning data would slowly become stuck - a semi-persistent resident magnetic field on the media. This can be fixed somewhat by writting zeros or 1's to the surface. I've had problem drives and zeroed it 10 or more times before it finally came good. I've also had a number that don't respond.
Some utilities would use this feature and you may actually recover a bad cluster. However there are some problems in doing that. Roughly speaking, a cluster is marked bad by a utility when it needs to be read more than an allocated number of times to retrieve the test data that was written. This means the cluster might be just making the grade.
If you worry about data loss, Scandisk /time -- marks any, slower than usual reads, as bad as well.

anenefan
Could you tell me what program is under Ontrack? I tried to find it on the internet and am not sure which one you mentioned? Thankyou

Hi
You want dataadvisor ver 5 -- it works for 30 days. The program also installs a shortcut without asking, on your desktop. I winge about it, as if you were able to find them in the first place there is no real need for such a shortcut.
http://www.ontrack.com/freesoftware/
http://www.ontrack.com/dataadvisor/

Hi
I forgot to ask again, the Hard drive -- what brand and model. There may well be a diagnostic available.

Hello anenefan,
I downloaded Data Advisor and passed all the tests. I'm going to check into some other things such as S.M.A.R.T. and try the other suggestion by jubalsams-Response Number 3.
I'll be back if I feel I need more help.
thankyou for your help, I really appreciate it
alot :)-Pyro

If anyone should take interest, I just found a link to S.M.A.R.T.(diagnostic-drive-hard-tool) here:
http://www.disk-utility.com/diagnostic-drive-hard-tool.html

Hi
Ontrack should test that (smart). Ontrack's tools were used by hard drive manufactures for quite a while.
Your link points to.
http://www.ariolic.com/activesmart/I've tried this program a while back and it wasn't a pleasant experience uninstalling it,
Again Ontack data advisor should have tested that -- Smart..
If you havn't scanned for virii, do so. Use another version of scandisk or use the bootup dos version on the 98 install disk. The windows version is Scandskw.exe should you feel the need to use the system file checker (or just type in at Run the command SFC) to replace this file. (Only that file)
Don't use an earlier dos version of scandisk.
It would be an idea to get a second hard drive. Any laptop hard drive should be compatible so long as it does not exceed the bios hard drive size limitation.

anenefan,
I got the results from SMART, my Hard Drive is
almost shot and my puter is showing it. I spent
my time backing up everything. I'm going to see about replacing the disk drive asap. Thank you for all your help-Pyro

Hi
Very good you were able to back up. And wise to get another hard drive.
As to testing SMART -- ??? You stated it passed alll Ontracks tests.
Put it this way -- Ontrack have been about for a bit. Hard drive manufactures actually supplied a version of Ontracks diagnostics for a while there.
Chances are if it passed Ontracks SMART test then its OK.
If you have actually backed "all" fo the drive, including window and program dir -- I would do this.
Use Killdisk the free version to wipe your disk.
If you have bad clusters, I think you will have to select "skip" from time to time.OK that done fire up the win98se install disk. Boot to dos with cd support.
OK go to the win98 dir [cd win98 ]
Try scandisk /surface
After that is done note how much was bad.
Now try scandisk /time
I'd be interested to see how much more of the disk is marked as bad.

Hey there,
HDD regenerator reports fixed sectors as still bad in scandisk unless you repartition the drive to update the marked sectors.Here is what the website says:
Note HDD Regenerator does not change the logical structure of a hard disk drive. Therefore the file system may contain logical bad sectors marked earlier, and other disk utilities such as Scandisk will detect bad sectors even if the hard drive is successfully regenerated by HDD Regenerator. To remove non-existent bad sectors from the file table, repartition your hard disk drive or use PowerQuest PartitionMagic (Bad Sector Retest option)

![]() |
![]() |
![]() |

This post is quite old and has been locked from receiving new replies. Please create a new posting instead.
| Ads by Google |