Tom's Guide | Tom's Hardware | Tom's Games
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
I read the post by "confused one": "Why do people badmouth compaq".
This has got me concerned.
I have a Compaq Presario 5476, it has 128mb SDRAM, 500mhz celeron, 10gb ultra DMA HD, Intel chipset810 & 8mb 3D AGP graphics thing, 6xDVD/32xCD-ROM and 17" MV720 monitor. It runs on win98se & I've got office 2000 premium installed. It came with an HP 810 printer and mustek scanner.
I've had a couple of problems with it, i.e. directdraw.dll failure leading to desktop becoming unusable, so I had to reinstall windows, also the DVD quality is poor (I'm trying to sort that out with compaq at the moment). Other than that (and the expected windows errors) it has worked fine.
However reading some of the posts it is evident that many people think compaq machines are of a poor quality. As I said this concerns me as I'm will probably have this machine for quite a long time.
If anyone wants to discuss this issue or can think of any particular problems I might get with my Compaq system then it would be good if you could reply to this post. Thanks.

My only complaint about Compaq is that they are notoriosly slow. A different brand computer with that same processor would be noticably faster. I have also noticed this about Gateways too.

personally, i build all my computers. you can find books or help online to do this. it sounds to me though like you have a decent setup for now. if you're happy with your computer, don't worry about what anyone else says. but next time try building it yourself. it's a very rewarding thing and you know everything about it, so if anyting goes wrong, you'll know what it is.

I don't know that Compaq is necessarily "no good" My personal dislike is for most "Brand name machines" because they are limited in being upgradable (some I'm told have the RAM soldered to the mobo) and that they use proprietary parts. That is you have to buy your parts from the maker of your system. And make no mistake about it this is by design. The parts are exorbitantly priced.
I had a Packard Bell for several years and you won't find much good said about them either. It was my introduction to proprietary computer parts. I thought I'd buy a spare mobo for it just in case! guess what in 1998 PB wanted $1074.00 for a 75mhz Pentium mobo. I found a better use for the computer as a boat anchor!!

For service or upgrading, Compaqs have long been the absolute WORST.
Proprietary integration of video, sound and/or modem onto the motherboard lowers their initial cost...but causes nightmares and/or complete gutting of the sys to replace what SHOULD have only been a $60 componnent and 10 minutes worth of work.
They also play games w/ requiring special (and very expensive) ram....and Lord knows where/what is going on w/ their BIOS from model to model.
Compaq gets away with this nonsense because many folx just "granny browse" and never open the "box".
Under similar price pressures, other major brands are following suit.
If "rolling your own" sounds a bit daunting, at the VERY LEAST consider a more standard/open design. Look at the back of the "box". Make sure that video, sound, and modem are all replacable expansion cards and not connected on the same plane as the parallel/serial connectors in back...directly to maboard.
Quit buying "namebrand" computers of no-name componnents. The often "lowlier" brand is a more open design...servicable and upgradable cheaply and as needed w/o some silly model-specific gotcha.
Your local mom 'n pop store is usually the best place to buy a "complete" computer. And they're more knowledgable and service oriented than the glorified warehouse personnel at Best Buy.

I own a Compaq and they are good computers until you want to upgrade. Proprietary hardware is a problem. Even the bays in a Compaq is propritary and Customer Service and tech support isn't all that great at all. I would say personally if you don't crack open your compaq, its a fine piece of machinery. However, once you want to upgrade a Compaq, Watch out!!!!
I was helping a friend who had a Compaq Presario I think is was the 8700 series. It was a great computer. But when he wanted to add more RAM and we crack it open it was so difficult to get to the RAM or the PCI slots. They had it do badly configured that if you took it to a local computer store, they would probably charge you 100 dollars just to open the sucker.
My opinion is to build your own from scratch. You won't have any surprises when you need to upgrade. But if you don't want to, I recommend going to a reputable local computer dealership versus the conglomerate "name brand" computer companies.Rod

I have found that Compaq, Dell, HP, etc. may be good computers but I don't like the upgrade or manufacturer specific items that you have to use. In other words you will find out that to upgrade or add other devices to your computer you will have to get these items from Compaq, etc. These items will be more expensive than a generic name brand item. I have personally built three seperate computer systems and have learned a lot doing it as well as I can upgrade or add other devices without any problems or complications. I also know what is on my system and a pretty good idea of what has gone wrong when it does.

I bought a 5030 2 1/2 years ago. I have had three modems replaced. The first one never worked. They finally sent me a commercial modem that worked immediatly unlike the rockwell.
The first month the CD rom was replaced.
Shortly thereafter a new processer,motherboard & memory.
Then a repeat replacement of the above. And finally the hard drive.
Oh yeah, Even my compaq monitor stopped working and had to be replaced.
Hundreds of hours of phone tech support. Dozens of case numbers. Several visits to the shop. And not to forget many patches and fixes to download and install for this product.
And everytime I formated and restored the computer per tech support I had to reinstall every patch all over.
They even told me I couldn't download the latest Internet explorer from the microsoft site. I had to get it from Altavista as it was made just for my computer and I would have big problems if I didn't. Proprietary for sure!
The end result was going to the top.Pitching a fit! They bought my machine back.
I now own a Sony Vaio. So far, so good! And so far fixes and patches needed! ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
Hopefully it was just a bad Compaq series! I wish they would not put the machines on the shelf so fast and let us find the problems. Then they make patches.

i met a lady that bought her 2120 persario at a police auction. needles to say, there was alot of unwanted data on the HD. Her husband formated the HD then brought it to me becouse after installing the new OS, they ended up with no sound,no modem and poor video...
i spent about a month searching for drivers to correct the problem with verry little help from the comcrap site and noticed that every system had a restore CD...
if nothing else, i could replace the modem with a replacement part stated on the origonal modem...i went to every compaq dealer in town to get a new restore CD for the system but they told me there was no such thing..no modem either. (yes,they were legit. compaq dealers) they called compaq for the fix to my problem and left me empty handed. i then called compaq myself to obtain a restore cd or a replacemet modem and was told that they didnt exist...
i ended up talking to a business owner who has a contract with compaq, he called up and pulled some strings..gues what, i finally got my restore CD,,,,, the system was up in 30 min......
why so much work for so little of a machine?? its the compaq way!!!1

![]() |
ringcentralfax
|
CD-ROM without sound card
|

This post is quite old and has been locked from receiving new replies. Please create a new posting instead.
| Ads by Google |