Hey bhaskardotbasu,You got what i got from Realtek. DOUBLTALK! Basically "we don't support the very basics a PC should be able to do...like have a mixer that isn't crippled and has fully active recording and playback sliders and supports tv cards adequately."
"Sorry...but we do follow microsofts HD audio protocals...blah blah"
If that's the case...maybe we shud be shoutin at microsoft instead of Realtek? :p
At least Realtek responded. I never heard back from Biostar and there is no phone support for either of them.
Well....here's a follow up.
The tv/audio situation is semi-patched up. It will never be fully patched until mobo mfrs get enough complaints that they stop using Realtek...then maybe Realtek will fix their crippled mixers.
Looking around for sub $50 cards I came across 3 or 4 immediately that had enough jacks, priced from $15 to 30+. Only problem was they looked familiar. Closer look and they were all based on the EXACT same C-media card as the junky mad dog card I tried (above posts). 2 of the clones were at Newegg under different names and a 3rd was a $19 compusa branded card. - Sneaky Re-branding of junk!
I don't remember if the card I ended up with is based on C-media or realtek... but the mixer isn't as crippled and sounds halfway decent.
I ended up with a Diamond Extreme sound 7.1 24 bit card from Office depot for $30. Lots of jacks. Works well enough. No buzz on tv audio. All sliders work EXCEPT Master Rec.Stereo LR Mixer sliders.(yep this mixer is partially crippled too). Master rec sliders are disabled at 50%. They need to be around 75%.
If you crank sub-sliders for wav, line in etc....all the way up...audio in audacity shows -12db max. Not terrible but I prefer 0 or better for better signal to noise ratio during playback.
For audio productions with audacity or similar software you need to go into the amplifier effect in POST production and have it auto correct for proper audio output level and save. AN extra step we shouldnt have to do....but that's how it is.
TV recorded audio is a bit lower than it should be but you can raise the volume on the playback device or pc...and NO BUZZ!
Speaking of volume....the tv remote does work with this Diamond sound card...BUT...because of the locked out rec sliders does NOT work the same as an AC97 setup. It's of course...another work-around.
With AC97 you can record with the tv volume set to zero and it will still record normal audio levels. You can also listen to a CD, MP3 winamp etc without interfering with your recording. Not with this next generation card.
I believe it has to do with the disabled Master stereo rec sliders. There are a few ways to set it up to rec. tv audio.
1. Rec tv audio from Stereo mixer (but then u have to disable ALL PC sounds or you'll have bleeps blips and blings on your tv recording unless u disable PC sounds in Control Panel.)
2. Rec audio from Line in only. By using method 2 and setting the remote to control Stereo mixer volume you can raise and lower volume during tv recording without affecting the recording. Since you're controlling Master system volume tho with the tv volume you can't listen to music at the same time. It's either Music or TV.
It works...just not like the old tech. Why are new things worse sometimes??
There is NO perfect solution here.... but for $30 this is workable at the moment. I just hate to have to come up with more $ and work-arounds for what is supposed to be a PC upgrade with MORE functionality than my 4 year old PCs....NOT less!
One step forward....and 15 steps back...I guess....
Guess we're at their mercy.
P.S. (Wonder how much lead exposure I got installing my made in China Biostar mobo? LOL!!)
oh yeah....one more tip: For an add on sound card....disable onboard audio first in device manager to avoid driver conflicts. Right click on my computer. Go to Hardware, Device Mgr then look for the Sound, game controller tree and expand it. Look for HD audio controller and right click for properties then at the bottom where it says device usage...use the drop down and click DISABLE - do not use. Then go to add/remove programs and uninstall the Realtek mixer. Shut down, then install your new sound card...reboot and install the software and drivers.
DON'T Disable your legacy audio. JUST the one that says HD audio controller. That's Realtek. If its not in the Sound, game controller tree it might be in system devices.
Best of luck!
Dave