Tom's Guide | Tom's Hardware | Tom's Games
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
Although once upon a time I owned a couple of Mac SE's, I have been a Wintel user for the last several years. I build my own PCs, and am generally pleased and impressed with XP Pro (my current OS for both household desktops).
Having said that, I still chafe at being being in more or less constant servitude to Redmond and have been looking at alternatives. Although I have dabbled in Linux, I still don't feel the desktop is ready for primetime (I will use it for servers ANY DAY.) Now to the point of my question:
I understand that just about any Open Source (*nix) program can be compiled and run on the new OS X, since it is roughly BSD-based. This and this alone is what has turned my head toward Macs. My problem is I don't know if I can successfully integrate a Mac into my network (and I don't trust the salespeople for a straight answer). Here is my setup:
Cable modem, Linksys Router/Firewall/DHCP Server, Samsung ML-1210 laser printer hooked up to my current desktop, HP Deskjet color inkjet hooked up to my wife's desktop, Canopus ADVC-100 video capture device hooked up to my machine via firewire, Microtek Scanmaker 3600 hooked up to my machine via USB, external USB 2.0 hard drive, old HP Netserver running Mandrake 8.2 in the garage.
Does anyone see any huge problems in getting this all to play nice with a new iBook? I would REALLY appreciate your thoughts/comments.

I have a Powerbook G4 which talks to a
Linksys WAP which plugs into a Linsys
router (now just a switch) which then
plugs into a FreeBSD box running on a
PC which bridges to the Internet via a
cable modem. (Say that in one breath!)The setup has worked seamlessly. The
only drawback is that the Linksys WAP
can't pass AppleTalk packets...for now. I
can't vouch for integration into PC
networks but I have read many other
favorable accounts and it truly seems like
Apple has bent over backwards to insure
network compatibility across platforms.
They really have no choice and
compatibility is very likely only going to get
better.
hth,
Damien

I have an ibook and I love it,but I can't upgrade it,if
you want a mac that's gonna grow with your
network,buy an older g3 tower!
Under the hood it's pretty much is an ibook except
you can add hardware to it.
If you have the cash a powerbook g4 could do the
job it has all the ports a portable should have and
more!
As for your linux question I had the same one
here's a link that pickle suggested.http://fink.sourceforge.net/

As far as getting the iBook on the internet, there shouldn't be a problem. As I'm sure you know, all *nixes have TCP/IP native, so just make sure the Mac's set for DHCP (unless you assign static IPs, of course) and you should have any problems.
Printing could be an issue. If Mac OS X drivers are available for your printers, it may be possible to share them off of the PCs. I've not really tried to do this yet, but it may work. You could always connect to one of the XP boxes (X connects beautifully to SMB shares), transfer the files, and print them from that machine. It's not as convenient, but it may be easier than making the other way work and cheaper than buying new printers.
The video capture, scanner, and USB HD should also work as long as Apple Drivers are available for them. In fact, between iMovie and iPhoto, you may not even need any other software for the first two devices.
OS X should also connect to your Linux machine without a problem. As I said, SMB shares can be used, TCP/IP is native, and it's *nix to *nix, so users/groups should work fine as is (if you are using them, that is).
-Chad

NO usb 2.0 on ibook,no upgrades,no drivers,no
word if apple will make it available to the ibook,as
for connecting via 10/100,that will work for
sure!.on almost any compute.r

True, the iBook does not have USB 2.0, but most (at least many) 2.0 devices are backward compatible. You can use them, but you won't get the throughput you would get from a 2.0 device.
Also, Andy, what "upgrades" are you looking for? Memory can easily (though not exactly cheaply) be upgraded, and you're most likely stuck with the slower USB 1.1 until the next major overhaul of the iBook, but what else would you want to upgrade? You can drop pretty much any capacity hard drive in there that will physically fit. And yes, memory tops out at 640Mb, but for the iBook's target audience, that's more than adequate. Yes, the TiBook offers far more flexibility, but it's also significantly more expensive. With Macs, you usually get what you pay for.
-Chad

No,but the person posting this has a 2.0 hd,and if
he gets an ibook he wont be able to use it.

Without knowing the brand and model of the drive, I can't say for sure, but it most likely will work since many USB 2.0 devices are backward compatible to work with USB 1.1 ports. The I/O speed is limited to 12Mbps, rather than 2.0's alleged 450Mbps, but it will probably still work just fine.
If Hammer45 could provide the brand, model and size of that USB HD, I (or anyone else with a web browser, really) could check and see if it is backward compatible. Simply saying "No, it won't work" without having that information is like your mechanic saying "Nope, can't fix it" before you even tell him what's wrong with your car! A little knowledge is a dangerous thing...enough knowledge is a very powerful thing.
-Chad

Go ahead try it,what's the worse that could
happen( besides buying an ibook only to relize
that it doesn't?),and as for 2.0 working on a
standard usb????????????,apple told me that
usb 2.0 is not supported by the ibook,and that the
only thing I could do for now was go firewire if
possible!,but if it does work that's great :),(let us
know!!!)

And if he really needs the speed, an external FireWire case (which the case he has now *might* be capable of - a lot of FireWire cases have USB2 hookups as well) is only $100 or so.
p

The USB 2.0 HD has successfully been used with a 1.1 hookup in Windows - comes up with a warning but works nonetheless. I will have to settle for the snail speed for now, as all my $$ will go toward the iBook.
BTW, thanks for all the responses - once I complete the purchase and get the iBook hooked up I'll let you know how it went.

Apart from lack of upgrade options you should be
happy with your ibook,I have mine running os 9.2/
10.1.5/win98 2nd and it runs them all very well.
But if you only have 128mb ram your os x alone
will still run at killer speeds.
Also apple load the ibook's with alot of junk when
them ship them,so the first boot's is the ideal time
to do a partition,(linux/mac).

![]() |
![]() |
![]() |

This post is quite old and has been locked from receiving new replies. Please create a new posting instead.
| Ads by Google |