|"holy crap those r nice"|
All those cards suck for gaming. The 9200SE that you mentioned is slower than both the FX5200 & GF 6200, plus it doesn't support DX9. None of them are anywhere near as good as the Radeon 9550 you mucked up. Next time, unplug the power cord before you go messing around inside the case.
Here's an AGP benchmark chart from over 7 yrs ago. The Radeon 9550 is roughly equal to the FX5700. The Radeon 9200SE isn't on the list but it's slower than the 9600SE (SE = Slow Edition):