Tom's Guide | Tom's Hardware | Tom's Games
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
Hey everyone my question is this..
I've been reading up on resolutions and what
resolutions for certain media (DVD, HD 720p,
HD 1080p, etc) and I cannot find the answer
to this question.So say you have a movie file that is 720p
which is 1280 x 720 (I believe)If I play that file on my 22" computer
monitor compared to playing it on my 50"
plasma tv (both digital, one is DVI one is
HDMI) it seems as though the TV has the
BETTER quality even though it is LARGER.How is it that this works? I have been
curious about this for some time and I would
appreciate it if someone could explain this
to me or if they could point me in the right
direction as to an explanation for it.Whats going on in my mind right now is I
think 1280 x 720 so I think 1280 pixels
across and 720 up but for a TV that is much
larger in size than a monitor wouldnt that
DECREASE quality? Im stumped.500W PS
Radeon HD X2600
Gigabyte P35-DS3L
2gb Ballistix 4-4-4-12 DDR2

I should add that the "native" resolution my
my 22" monitor is 1680 x 1050 and the 50"
plasma tv is 720 p (1280 x 720 native) so how
does that also play into the scheme of
things?For example say I am playing a video file in
DVD quality (720 x 480 I believe), is it
because the tv does not have to downscale as
much as the computer monitor that it seems to
look better?Also how is it that screens can get bigger
but have smaller resolution and still look
good?500W PS
Radeon HD X2600
Gigabyte P35-DS3L
2gb Ballistix 4-4-4-12 DDR2

Plasmas are better for video than LCDs (especially LCD PC monitors, which typically use cheap panels). Plasmas have great colour accuracy, high contrast ratios, and fast video response time.
You're probably watching the 50" TV from quite a ways away, which makes compression artifacts hard to discern.
Video on your monitor (especially SD DVD content) has two things against it: (1) The monitor's high resolution makes the macroblocking of a 480p MPEG-2 stream quite obvious, and (2) you're sitting very close to your monitor, which makes macroblocking, well, even more obvious. Nearly every imperfection in the video stream becomes visible.
As for the 720p HD file: It will definitely look good on your TV because it doesn't have to be scaled to fit your 720p TV. In most cases, scaling reduces image quality (especially at "weird" resolutions like 1680x1050).
"For example say I am playing a video file in DVD quality (720 x 480 I believe), is it because the tv does not have to downscale as much as the computer monitor that it seems to look better?"
If the TV is hooked up to an HDMI DVD player, then you're getting a 720p video signal from the DVD player. This results in a sharper image than a PC-based player. A PC-based DVD player simply blows up the 480p image--without any further processing--to fill an HD screen. This results in visible blockiness, just as the magnification of a photo in Photoshop would. A decent HDMI DVD player, however, does some number crunching to produce decent 720p - 1080i/p output from a 480p DVD. It's not as good as real HD, and cheap players don't do nearly as well as expensive players, but it's always an improvement over the non-processed 480p delivered over YPbPr component.
Clear as mud?
Replacing Super P3:
Pentium M Dothan @ 2.82GHz (166x17)
3GB PC2-6400 @ 667MHz
9600GT
Blu-Ray
Modified PowerMac G4 Quicksilver case
Homebuilt 1920x1200 projector
Vista x86

Thanks a lot, the post did provide some
useful information.I should add that the "DVD" file I was
playing was a file I had downloaded onto my
computer and I watched it both on the
computer monitor and the tv (video card has
two output DVI ports, one I use a DVI to HDMI
dongle to hook it up to the tv)Sitting far away from both the computer and
tv it looks like the tv is more "lively"
compared to the computer monitor. As for
blockiness the tv might win by a short
margin.So if I am playing this dvd quality file on
my computer on the tv it should still look
better, I assume, because of the tvs features
in bringing out the best of a picture.I did try use the Catalyst Control Center
(ATI's) to make the monitor Vivid in color
and it helped a bit.Thanks for the information!
500W PS
Radeon HD X2600
Gigabyte P35-DS3L
2gb Ballistix 4-4-4-12 DDR2

One last question (i hope)
Though my monitor is 1680 x 1050 native
resolution, would changing the resolution to
something like 1024 x 768 make it look better
when i play certain resolution video files? I
dont think this is the case but I was
curious.500W PS
Radeon HD X2600
Gigabyte P35-DS3L
2gb Ballistix 4-4-4-12 DDR2

![]() |
![]() |
![]() |

This post is quite old and has been locked from receiving new replies. Please create a new posting instead.
| Ads by Google |