Tom's Guide | Tom's Hardware | Tom's Games
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
Name: srloren
After a year, my friend's HP desktop computer has not been working right. The monitor would not show anything. He purchased a 3 year warantee from Staples, where he purchased the computer and it has been almost a month since it broke. He contacted them right away. They have taken all of this time waiting for the part to be shipped and a tech to come out to install each part that they thought was broken. What if he had a business that depended on this computer? Needless to say he will not be shopping at Staples ever again. HP shipped out a new harddrive and a tech came out and installed it. Still not working. Then after a week and a half they sent the tech back with a video board. Still not working. Now they say it might be the monitor. My question is could his power supply put out more voltage that it should and if I took my monitor to his home and connected it, could it harm my computer? I am just trying to shorten up the time that he is out of service.
Your advice on the above would be appreciated. Thanks much.

Staples Easy Mobil Tech is to Staples what Geek Squad is to Best Buy. Just because all technies have A+ certificates does not mean each is the most qualified to do the job right. Your use of this service is Caveat emptor (Latin for "let the buyer beware".)
i_XpUser

XPUser, I follow this forum sometimes and your answers to tech questions seem to be respected by others who have experience. I am therefore wondering why you did not tackle my question regarding using my monitor on his system to verify that his monitor was defective. Please respond if you have time. Thanks again.

Thanks but because it's your verbal description is what is really involved I cannot give you suggestion until I see it myself. Otherwise I would feel guilty if I tell you to go ahead and hook up your monitor and then it ruins yours too!
i_XpUser

most monitors have a self test feature check. disconnect the monitor from the back of the system tower then turn it back on. if you see the self check, the monitor is working. if not, then its dead.
i wish i were what i wished i were before i wished i were what i am now...

XPUser, thanks for your answer...you have expressed that may not connect the monitor because it could cause harm. I will tell my friend this because I offered to come over today to try to help him. One other question. I assume the same caveat apply if he were to bring his monitor to my home and plug it into my system? Thanks again...you are a valued asset to this forum.

Regarding your question about 'What if he had a business?'. This is why businesses don't buy their computers through Staples and why they have IT departments and accounts through the manufacturer (IBM/HP/Dell/etc) versus warranties through the resellers that dont even work on the mahcines, they just ship them to the manufacturer which takes for ever.

Excellent points. He overpaid for the warantee...it was $300. plus. He has asked them to just replace his computer and he they told him that it doesn't work like that. They have one way of solving problems and that is jus the way it is. You can see that their attitude about customer service after one has gone to the expense of getting a warantee really sucks. Back in the late 60s there was a book called "The Peter Principal" by Lawrence J. Peter, it was about why things go wrong....It was on the best sellers list for over 6 months and it applies more than ever today.

I assume the same caveat apply if he were to bring his monitor to my home and plug it into my system?
Yes but it's your call. If the PC you have is your everyday-use PC, are you willing to take the risk to possibly damage it.
Speaking of paid tech support, read this article...
Also from PcMag perspective...
Who You Gonna Call to Solve PC Crises? Be sure you see the performance test chart. What a sucker to use such service like this. I am grateful I stayed with CN to learn something new everyday.
i_XpUser

Their are two risky parts of swapping monitors:
1. Dropping the monitor in transit.
2. Bending or breaking a pin in the cable connector (not very likely).Other that that it's pretty safe.
Sorry, I do not check for private messages

I think your friend's experience is fairly typical of warranty service in general, and it's not going to get much better at any major computer retailer. For that matter, the same goes for cars, boats, houses, et al.
Personally, I've usually found Staples to be a pretty decent company to work with, although I've never been sucked into buying a warranty. But it's the one company that gets me mail-in-rebates consistently and on time (thanks to their very cool, online ezrebate system where you don't have to mail anything in), and that alone is worth the few extra dollars up front I might pay there.
I worked as a programmer for Insight (insight.com & the insight bowl) for some time, and the pressure on the sales reps to attach warranties to just about everything is intense. Retail is a low margin business - when you're competing against companies like newegg, you're lucky to squeeze out your cost. But warranties and service contracts are very high margin, and can really keep you in business.
I do believe in getting the extended warranties on two things: 1. Flat-screen monitors and 2. Laptops. I only have anecdotal evidence, but it seems like both of those items have lifetimes that on average are around that of the warranty.
As for hooking your monitor up to his system, or hooking his monitor up to your system, just go for it. It may be possible, but I've never heard of the PSU damaging the monitor. You're not going to break anything.
Good luck,
-SN

Thanks for the compliments regarding Staples in general.
Personally I patronize this chain store regularly becase (1) it's well-stocked office supplies "warehouse" (2) they have copiers (both B&W and color) (3) the online rebate process saved me a lot of paperwork (& stamps), (4) they have a branch within walking distance from where I live. The only thing I never purchased or used is Staples Easy Mobil Tech paid service support.
Regarding the paid service support I believe all chain stores recognized it as a money-making business opportunity. The majority of customers who purchase such service are those who have no idea about the workings of a computer. You are right about the necessity of extended warranty only for LCD monitors & laptop.
Best regards
i_XpUser

![]() |
No sound through speakers
|
Dual Display Problem!
|

This post is quite old and has been locked from receiving new replies. Please create a new posting instead.
| Ads by Google |