Computing.Net > Forums > CPUs/Overclocking > P4 vs PIII vs AMD Athlon

Computer Problems? Computing.Net has over 1,000,000 posts about all things technology related! Click here to start participating now! Also, check out the New User Guide.

P4 vs PIII vs AMD Athlon

Reply to Message Icon

Name: Wakar (by Waks)
Date: January 28, 2002 at 13:29:26 Pacific
Comment:

This is my dilema....

I am going to build a PC myself in the coming weeks...however i am not sure which processor to buy. I have read reviews on the P4 and they dont seem to be good... well not 70% of them anyway. The PIII seems to be the more stable and suggessted processor to use. And as a after thought the AMD Athlon has out performed the P4 in recent tests..

So i would like to hear from people who have are using the processors mentioned and let me know what they think of it and finally what i should use to build my system.

I will be using my system for applications such as office, surfing the net, building web sites, and maybe some games now and again but nothing too powerful.

All help is greatfully appreciated and thanks in advance

Waks



Sponsored Link
Ads by Google

Response Number 1
Name: EmAzY
Date: January 28, 2002 at 16:02:07 Pacific
Reply:

get a AMD ATHLON Xp


0

Response Number 2
Name: Dragon
Date: January 28, 2002 at 23:39:09 Pacific
Reply:

Go with an AMD Athlon and a good heatsink/fan and you will be set. You will get top of the line performance and save money. If you want a great system but don't need top of the line than you can go with AMD Duron. That'll save you big bucks and still give you great performance.


0

Response Number 3
Name: Steve
Date: January 29, 2002 at 00:30:14 Pacific
Reply:

Just be careful of the heat, it can get pretty hot in an AMD case without at least a couple of fans


0

Response Number 4
Name: juzmyopinion
Date: January 29, 2002 at 09:11:50 Pacific
Reply:

Have to agree with all that have suggested Athlons or even the duron in the previous posts. Athlons are cheaper than a P3..unless you go with an athlon XP. I kind of regret building up my P3...could have saved over a hundred dollars by building an athlon that would have been faster! Durons are good too if you have a low budget! Plus you can get the Athlons with the 266FSB and use DDR ram if your board supports it. And yes, as Steve suggested, you must keep it cool. A good CPU Fan and a couple case fans are are essential.


0

Response Number 5
Name: JRF
Date: January 29, 2002 at 18:23:56 Pacific
Reply:

Built a new P4 2 weeks ago P1.9, MSI 845 Ultra ARU; 512DDR. Incredibly fast, XP compatable and very stable. CPU temps at conatant 14C! Don't know what reviews you've read about the P4's but I did a lot of research and this mobo/chip combo reviews very highly with DDRram and outperforms anything I have used. AMD will run a little bit faster (you probably will not notice the difference) but it will not be as stable, run as cool and most VIA boards are not as XP friendly as Intel based boards. To sum up, both great options, it just depends what your using if for!

PS Don't go with the PIII - waste of money;I upgraded from a PIII 600 and this is another world.
JRF


0

Related Posts

See More



Response Number 6
Name: Jason
Date: January 29, 2002 at 21:33:28 Pacific
Reply:

I built an Athlon 1.4 DDR systems a few months back and had nothing but problems with it.

I have now gone back to Intel and purchased a P4 1.8A with DDR ram.

It wont be as fast as an Athlon system but is stable. You probably won't really notice the difference in speed unless you sit running benchmarks all day.

My vote is for Intel, on an Intel board.. VIA has given me to many headaches.

Jason.


0

Response Number 7
Name: mike
Date: January 30, 2002 at 11:10:21 Pacific
Reply:

athlon/VIA systems are ROCK solid if you set it up correctly. I have had a 1 Ghz t/bird OC'D to 1.2 for over a year with absolutely NO stability issues at all. I now have a 1.4/266 W/RAID 0 and it outperforms any intel systemI have ever seen...99% of computer problems (stability or otherwise) can be attributed to the device between the keyboard and the chair...


0

Response Number 8
Name: Martin
Date: January 31, 2002 at 04:08:34 Pacific
Reply:

AMD forever !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


0

Response Number 9
Name: EmAzY
Date: January 31, 2002 at 09:05:48 Pacific
Reply:

if your rich enough get P4 2.2 ghz and clock dat baby to 2.9 ghz... thats the reason the price is kinda high coz its the new champ for clocking....

but i like amd athlon xp better for the value and performance

payce


0

Response Number 10
Name: Adrian
Date: January 31, 2002 at 15:54:40 Pacific
Reply:

AMD's perform very well, TRUE but before you go that route take a look at the 1.26 PIII Tualatin with 512k cache. These chips have the .13 core, and they run at 1.45v. They don't even need a fan on the heatsink!
Check out http://www.accelenation.com/?doc=108&page=1 for an interesting article and comparison against AMD 1800mp.
It all comes down to budget. On a tight budget i would have to agree and say buy a Duron 1.2


0

Response Number 11
Name: widodo
Date: May 6, 2002 at 21:43:31 Pacific
Reply:

would you give me some suggestion about
P4 and AMD Athlon XP!
tank's


0

Response Number 12
Name: widodo
Date: May 6, 2002 at 21:43:39 Pacific
Reply:

would you give me some suggestion about
P4 and AMD Athlon XP!
thank's


0

Response Number 13
Name: Ace
Date: May 28, 2002 at 12:26:54 Pacific
Reply:

the only things taht P4 het beating by AMD, is the price!


0

Response Number 14
Name: jonas
Date: June 12, 2002 at 06:19:14 Pacific
Reply:

Don't buy a p4, it's too expensive, and i don't think that the reason for the instability of athlon-pc's is the cpu but it's probably the mb. If you buy a abit, asus, or a msi board you shouldn't have any problems. If you like too loose money give it to poor people but not to intel :)
I would buy a amd athlon XP 1800+ on a msi board with DDR. That's the very good performance for little money and it often lets you overclock to a 2300+ without stability problems (if you have a good heat-sink)...
good luck


0

Sponsored Link
Ads by Google
Reply to Message Icon

2nd processor LEX Mainboards



Post Locked

This post is quite old and has been locked from receiving new replies. Please create a new posting instead.


Go to CPUs/Overclocking Forum Home


Sponsored links

Ads by Google


Results for: P4 vs PIII vs AMD Athlon

Pentium4 3.2 VS AMD 64X2 Dual 5400+ www.computing.net/answers/cpus/pentium4-32-vs-amd-64x2-dual-5400/14906.html

p4 vs amd www.computing.net/answers/cpus/p4-vs-amd/2878.html

AMD 64 3000+ vs AMD X2 3800+ www.computing.net/answers/cpus/amd-64-3000-vs-amd-x2-3800/14028.html