Tom's Guide | Tom's Hardware | Tom's Games
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
Is there? I want to get a new HD since the one I have now is only 5gig :( I was looking at the prices and I noticed I could get an ATA100 5400RPM 40gig drive for about $50, whereas the ATA100 40gig HD runs about $100. I looked at all of them at pricewatch, and even though they run about $60 dollras, they like to addd about $45 dollars for shipping. As long as they run at the same speed of 100 is there a huge difference between the two? Also, does an 7200 RPM HD get really hot? That is the last thing I need in my PC is more fans, I have about 5 in there already. Thanks

It depends what you use the HDD for, if it is only for Windows/Gaming then a 5400 HDD will be fast enough. If your PC is going to be a small server or will be using theings like KAZAA over a broad band connection, then a 7200 drive will increase system performance by a few percent.
It if often a better idea to buy a more reputable 5400 drive, such as Western Digital or IBM, then an OEM 7200 or one of the cheaper Maxtor ranges.Joni

I have bought many hard drives in the past and I can tell you from experience that you (the user) will not notice a HUGE gain in speed/accessibility to your files if you use 7200 rpm over 5400 rpm. The only real difference is the price. Just get a larger 5400 rpm drive instead of the 40 gig 7200 rpm. You could get a 80 gig 5400 rpm drive by IBM from tigerdirect.com or pricewatch.com

Yeah, I will only be gaming, and downloading off of Kazaa :) So IBM will work in a PC? It is just the name brand or it right? Thanks

That's only true, depending on some of the following. For example:
1. Your hard disk performance will not *APPEAR* to be any faster at all, if you're upgrading to a much larger disk, since the write/seek time now takes longer, in order to access your data.
2. Even if the new and faster disk isn't much larger - there's still the question of: Are you using partitions (which you should anyway)? If you are, then the same thing applies as before - meaning that if your primary user partitions are 50 - 100 percent larger, the drive will require more seek time to get to the info., thereby making things apear to be just as slow or fast as before.
BUT - If you're upgrading from an old mobo with an old 8 or 10 GB UDMA33 drive, to the newer & large ATA100 or ATA133 drives, then you will absolutely see a difference in speed. Just be sure that you have a mobo that supports the newer ATA100/133 standard though - otherwise you'd be wasting your money (if you didn't replace the mobo in that case too).
I just upgraded my 30 GB 5400 RPM ATA100 drive to a 40 GB 7200 RPM drive by IBM, last night. I honestly wasn't expecting much of a difference, and I honestly didn't get much of a difference in speed. With a PC, it's the CPU, Memory, Hard Disk, *AND* Display Adapter that dictate actual and physical performance, quite literally as a team of sorts. The BEST and most VISUAL performance increase that I have ever seen in the past 5 - 10 years, has been by a really top notch display adapter. Those can make an immediate difference in your life, without changing the hard drive (unless you want to). Memory causes nice, smooth performance, and great stability for large applications and games. The chip (CPU) does that too. But again, an awesome 4X AGP display adapter over an old and worn out crap_y PCI adapter, will make everything perform faster than the difference of the two hard drive speeds that I mentioned above . . .
Hey Intel, AMD rulez!

On a new system you will see a big difference about 33% faster with the 7200 rpm.As leembo says if it is an old system it may not make much difference

Er........... 7200 rpm, faster. BUT make sure you get one with as much on board cache as you can. There are 8 meg cache versions available.
GO HERE
http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProduct.asp?submit=manufactory&manufactory=1306&catalog=14&DEPA=1&sortby=14&order=1FOR THIS ($106)
Blow Out Special WOW, WD WESTERN DIGITAL "SPECIAL EDITION" 80GB 7200RPM EIDE HARD DRIVE MODEL # WD800JB - OEM, DRIVE ONLY
Specifications:
Size: 80 Gigabytes
Interface: IDE ULTRA ATA100
Seek time: 8.9ms
RPM:7200
Cache 8MB
OEM(Drive alone) 3 Year Manufacturer Warranty --* Works With PC & Mac *--

Oh, and yeah, you might not notice much difference NOW, but in one year's time the games are going to be more demanding, the processor's faster and you ARE going to notice a difference.

If you put a 7200rpm disk on your pc and leave the 5400rpm in you will not see a difference if you have two drive in a pc your system will always adjust to the speed of the slow one that is why you have answer said no difference and other said big difference.

"On a new system you will see a big difference about 33% faster with the 7200 rpm"
33% faster at what? It amazes me how some people continually post useless and false data misleading those with simple questions. His computer certainly won't run any app 33% faster andcertainly won't run games 33% faster... File sharing like Kazaa (if people still use that newbie, leecher and virus laden POS, try direct connect since you're gettin a bigger hard drive and welcome to a superior file sharing experience :)
My point is that 33% an absurd statement to even be making such a claim. People can upgrade their cpu's and video cards at tremendous expense and often not get "33%".
My experience like the others is that there isn't much difference at all between to the two speeds and like previously mentioned, if you're on a budget get a well known name brand 5400 over a cheap 7200... cheap hard drives will die on you much sooner than you'd like, and it's a pain in the arse :)

In summary to what I stated earlier:
1.2 Ghz. Athlon
512 MB PC133 Ram
Switched ATA100 5400 rpm drive to a 30% LARGER ATA100 7200 rpm drive.Noticable performance increase?
VIRTUALLY NONE !!!Why? Because of the larger size on which the seek time is increased by virtue of the increased size, REGARDLESS of how fast the platters spin. When the drive spins faster, it still has to *SEEK* for the info. across the drive platters. Finding info. is a *TWO STEP* process - relating to spindle *SPEED* and the physical *SIZE* of the drive. Get it now?
So again, moving up from say, a partitioned 60 GB to a partitioned 80 GB drive, will NOT INCREASE PERFORMANCE a whole lot.
Hey Intel, AMD rulez!

I'll leave the 5400/7200 debate to you guys...what amazed me was the $100 for 40gb! Is that a standard price? I recently purchased a Western Digital 7200 Ultra/ATA 100gb drive for $100. And that was at the store, no shipping. It's installed and working as I type this.

![]() |
MSI 645 Ultra Bios Settin...
|
Noise reduction on heatsi...
|

This post is quite old and has been locked from receiving new replies. Please create a new posting instead.
| Ads by Google |